Global Goods Maturity: Difference between revisions

From Digital Square
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 276: Line 276:
|style="background-color:#96d68f; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 10
|style="background-color:#96d68f; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 10
|-
|-
|rowspan="1" style="border-bottom:solid 5px black" | [[#OpenFn|OpenFn]]
|rowspan="2" style="border-bottom:solid 5px black" | [[#OpenFn|OpenFn]]
|style="border-bottom:solid 5px black" | Baseline (July 2021)
|Baseline (July 2021)
|style="background-color:#f7e5ab" | 6
|style="background-color:#96d68f" | 7
|style="background-color:#f7e5ab" | 6
|rowspan="2" style="border-bottom:solid 5px black"| -1
|-
|style="border-bottom:solid 5px black" | Update (Sept 2022)
|style="background-color:#f7e5ab; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 6
|style="background-color:#f7e5ab; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 6
|style="background-color:#f7e5ab; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 6
|style="background-color:#96d68f; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 7
|style="background-color:#f7e5ab; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 6
|style="background-color:#f7e5ab; border-bottom:solid 5px black" | 6
|rowspan="1" style="border-bottom:solid 5px black"| N/A
|-
|-
|rowspan="1" style="border-bottom:solid 5px black" | [[#OpenHIE|OpenHIE]]
|rowspan="1" style="border-bottom:solid 5px black" | [[#OpenHIE|OpenHIE]]

Revision as of 15:42, 7 February 2023

Maturity of Global Goods: Summary Table

This table reflects the maturity model baseline assessments and the latest reassessment of global goods funded through Digital Square. All maturity model assessments are *self-reported* by the funded organization leading the software development of the global good. For more information about global good maturity models, please contact Carl Fourie at cfourie@path.org.

Global Good Global Utility Community Software Change
Bahmni Baseline (Jan 2018) 4 8 6 +9
Update (Aug 2020) 7 10 8
Update (Feb 2021) 7 10 8
Update (July 2021) 6 8 10
Update (Sept 2022) 7 10 10
CommCare Baseline (May 2019) 10 10 9 +1
Update (Jun 2020) 10 10 10
(July 2021) 10 10 10
Update (Sept 2022) 10 10 10
Community Health Toolkit Baseline (Jun 2018) 8 8 6 +6
Update (Jun 2020) 9 9 8
Update (July 2021) 9 10 9
Update (Sept 2022) 9 10 9
DHIS2 Baseline (Sep 2018) 9 8 8 +5
Update (Mar 2020) 10 8 10
Update (April 2021) 10 9 10
Update (Sept 2022) 10 10 10
GOFR Baseline (Jun 2019) 2 5 5 +4
Update (Jun 2020) 5 7 6
Update (Sept 2022) 4 5 7
Healthsites Baseline (March 2021) 6 8 8 N/A
iHRIS Baseline (Oct 2018) 8 6 9 -1
Update (Jun 2020) 8 9 9
Update (July 2021) 8 8 9
Update (Sept 2022) 9 7 6
mHero Baseline (Oct 2019) 2 1 4 +5
Update (Jun 2020) 4 2 4
Update (Dec 2020) 4 3 4
Update (July 2021) 3 3 5
Update (Sept 2022) 3 4 5
ODK Baseline (July 2021) 10 10 9 0
Update (Sept 2022) 10 10 9
ODK-X Baseline (July 2021) 7 9 6 N/A
OpenBoxes Baseline (July 2021) 5 5 4 +1
Update (July 2021) 5 5 5
Open Concept Lab Baseline (Mar 2018) 5 6 6 +3
Update (May 2020) 5 7 6
Update (July 2021) 5 7 6
Update (Sept 2022) 4 7 6
Update (Jan 2023) 6 7 7
OpenCRVS Baseline (Mar 2018) 0 1 3 +17
Update (May 2020) 4 5 10
Update (July 2021) 6 7 7
OpenELIS Baseline (Jun 2019) 1 4 7 +11
Update (Jun 2020) 6 6 7
Update (Sept 2022) 6 7 10
OpenFn Baseline (July 2021) 6 7 6 -1
Update (Sept 2022) 6 6 6
OpenHIE Baseline (July 2021) 8 6 1 N/A
OpenHIM Baseline 6 3 6 +3
Update (Jun 2020) 6 5 7
Update (July 2021) 6 5 7
openIMIS Baseline 4 7 4 +10
Update (Jun 2020) 6 10 8
Update (July 2021) 7 10 8
OpenLMIS Baseline (Aug 2018) 6 7 8 +1
Update (Jan 2020) 6 7 9
Update (July 2021) 6 7 9
OpenMRS Baseline (Jun 2019) 7 7 5 0
Update (Sept 2020) 7 7 5
OpenSRP Baseline (Jan 2018) 7 6 4 +4
Update (Jun 2019) 7 8 4
Update (Jun 2020) 9 9 6
Update (March 2021) 7 8 6
PCMT Baseline (July 2021) 8 9 7 N/A
Pharmadex Baseline (July 2021) 8 10 7 N/A
Reveal Baseline (July 2021) 5 7 6 N/A
SanteMPI Baseline (July 2021) 4 5 7 N/A
SORMAS Baseline (Jul 2017) 6 3 1 +20
Update 10 10 10
Tamanu Baseline (July 2021) 6 5 5 N/A

Digital Square Maturity Model Details

To help identify areas of investments for global goods, Digital Square has developed a Global Good Maturity Model for digital health tools. We continue to engage the digital health community, in particular the Digital Health and Interoperability Working Group of the Health Data Collaborative, in the development of this model.

Currently, the maturity model is in version 1.3, last updated June 2020. The initial version (1.1) was presented at the Global Digital Health Forum in December of 2017.

Maturity by Global Good

Bahmni

Category Baseline (Jan 2019) Update (Mar 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low Medium Medium
Country Strategy Low Medium Medium
Digital Health Interventions Medium High High
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue Medium Medium Low
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High High Medium
Community Governance High High High
Software Roadmap Medium High High
User Documentation High High High
Multi-lingual Support Medium High Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium High High
Software Productization Medium High High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High High High
Security Medium Medium High
Scalability Medium Medium High

CommCare

Category Baseline (May 2019) Update (Jun 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization High High High
Country Strategy High High High
Digital Health Interventions Medium High High
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue High High High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High High High
Community Governance High High High
Software Roadmap High High High
User Documentation High High High
Multi-lingual Support High High High
Software
Technical Documentation High High High
Software Productization High High High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High High High
Security Medium High High
Scalability High High High

Community Health Toolkit

Category Baseline (Jun 2018) Update (Jun 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium High High
Country Strategy High High High
Digital Health Interventions Medium Medium Medium
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue High High High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium High High
Community Governance Medium Medium High
Software Roadmap High High High
User Documentation High High High
Multi-lingual Support High High High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium High High
Software Productization High High High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium Medium High
Security Medium Medium Medium
Scalability Medium High High

DHIS2

Category Baseline (Sep 2018) Update (Mar 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization High High High
Country Strategy High High High
Digital Health Interventions Medium High High
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue High High High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium Medium High
Community Governance Medium Medium Medium
Software Roadmap High High High
User Documentation High High High
Multi-lingual Support High High High
Software
Technical Documentation High High High
Software Productization Medium High High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High High High
Security Medium High High
Scalability High High High

GOFR

Category Baseline (Jun 2019) Update (Jun 2020)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low High
Country Strategy Low Low
Digital Health Interventions Medium Medium
Source Code Accessibility Medium High
Funding and Revenue Low Low
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium High
Community Governance Medium Medium
Software Roadmap Medium Medium
User Documentation Medium High
Multi-lingual Support Medium Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium Medium
Software Productization Medium High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium Medium
Security Medium Medium
Scalability Medium Medium


Healthsites

Category Update (March 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium
Country Strategy Medium
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue Low
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High
Community Governance High
Software Roadmap Medium
User Documentation High
Multi-lingual Support Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium
Software Productization Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High
Security High
Scalability High

iHRIS

Category Baseline (Oct 2018) Update (Jun 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization High High High
Country Strategy Medium Medium Medium
Digital Health Interventions High High High
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue Medium Medium Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium Medium Medium
Community Governance Medium High High
Software Roadmap Low High High
User Documentation High High High
Multi-lingual Support High High Medium
Software
Technical Documentation High High High
Software Productization High High High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High High High
Security Medium Medium Medium
Scalability High High High

mHero

Category Baseline (Oct 2019) Update (Jun 2020) Update (Dec 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low Medium Medium Low
Country Strategy Low Low Low Low
Digital Health Interventions Medium Medium Medium Medium
Source Code Accessibility Medium Medium Medium Medium
Funding and Revenue Low Medium Medium Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Low Low Low Low
Community Governance Low Low Low Low
Software Roadmap Low Low Low Low
User Documentation Medium High High High
Multi-lingual Support Low Low Medium Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium Medium Medium Medium
Software Productization Medium Medium Medium Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium Medium Medium Medium
Security Medium Medium Medium Medium
Scalability Low Low Low Medium

ODK

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization High
Country Strategy High
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High
Community Governance High
Software Roadmap High
User Documentation High
Multi-lingual Support High
Software
Technical Documentation High
Software Productization High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High
Security Medium
Scalability High

ODK-X

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low
Country Strategy High
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High
Community Governance High
Software Roadmap High
User Documentation High
Multi-lingual Support Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium
Software Productization High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium
Security Medium
Scalability Medium

OpenBoxes

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low
Country Strategy Low
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium
Community Governance Medium
Software Roadmap Medium
User Documentation Medium
Multi-lingual Support Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium
Software Productization Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium
Security Medium
Scalability Low

Open Concept Lab

Category Baseline (Mar 2018) Update (May 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low Low Low
Country Strategy Low Low Low
Digital Health Interventions High High High
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue Medium Medium Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium High High
Community Governance Medium Medium Medium
Software Roadmap Medium Medium Medium
User Documentation Medium Medium Medium
Multi-lingual Support High High High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium Medium Medium
Software Productization Medium Medium Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High High High
Security Medium Medium Medium
Scalability Medium Medium Medium

OpenCRVS

Category Baseline (Mar 2018) Update (May 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low Low Low
Country Strategy Low Low Medium
Digital Health Interventions Low High High
Source Code Accessibility Low High High
Funding and Revenue Low Low Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Low Medium Medium
Community Governance Low Medium Medium
Software Roadmap Medium Low Medium
User Documentation Low High High
Multi-lingual Support Low Medium High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium High High
Software Productization Low High Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium High High
Security Medium High High
Scalability Low High Low

OpenELIS

Category Baseline (Jun 2019) Update (Jun 2020)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low Medium
Country Strategy Low Medium
Digital Health Interventions Medium High
Source Code Accessibility Low Medium
Funding and Revenue Low Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium Medium
Community Governance Medium Medium
Software Roadmap Low Medium
User Documentation Medium Medium
Multi-lingual Support Medium High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium Medium
Software Productization Medium Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High High
Security High High
Scalability Medium Medium

OpenFn

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low
Country Strategy Low
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium
Community Governance High
Software Roadmap Medium
User Documentation Medium
Multi-lingual Support High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium
Software Productization High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High
Security Medium
Scalability Low

OpenHIE (Content Global Good)

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization High
Country Strategy High
Digital Health Interventions N/A
Source Code Accessibility N/A
Funding and Revenue Low
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High
Community Governance High
Software Roadmap Medium
User Documentation Medium
Multi-lingual Support Low
Software
Technical Documentation N/A
Software Productization N/A
Interoperability and Data Accessibility N/A
Security N/A
Scalability N/A

OpenHIM

Category Baseline Update (Jun 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium Medium Medium
Country Strategy Medium Medium Medium
Digital Health Interventions Medium Medium Medium
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue Medium Medium Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium Medium Medium
Community Governance Medium Medium Medium
Software Roadmap Low Medium Medium
User Documentation Medium High High
Multi-lingual Support Low Low Low
Software
Technical Documentation Medium High High
Software Productization Medium Medium Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium Medium High
Security High High Medium
Scalability Medium Medium Medium

openIMIS

Category Baseline Update (Jun 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low Medium Medium
Country Strategy Low Medium Medium
Digital Health Interventions Medium Medium Medium
Source Code Accessibility Medium Medium High
Funding and Revenue High High High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High High High
Community Governance High High High
Software Roadmap Medium High High
User Documentation Medium High High
Multi-lingual Support Medium High High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium Medium Medium
Software Productization Medium High High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium High High
Security Medium Medium Medium
Scalability Low High High

OpenLMIS

Category Baseline (Aug 2018) Update (Jan 2020) Update (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium Medium Medium
Country Strategy Medium Medium Medium
Digital Health Interventions High High High
Source Code Accessibility High High High
Funding and Revenue Low Low Low
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium Medium Medium
Community Governance High High High
Software Roadmap High High High
User Documentation Medium Medium Medium
Multi-lingual Support Medium Medium Medium
Software
Technical Documentation High High High
Software Productization High High High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High High High
Security Medium Medium Medium
Scalability Medium High High

OpenMRS

Category Baseline (Jun 2019) Update (Sept 2020)
Global Utility
Country Utilization High High
Country Strategy Medium Medium
Digital Health Interventions Medium Medium
Source Code Accessibility High High
Funding and Revenue Medium Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High High
Community Governance High High
Software Roadmap Medium Medium
User Documentation Medium Medium
Multi-lingual Support Medium Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium Medium
Software Productization Medium Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium Medium
Security Medium Medium
Scalability Medium Medium

OpenSRP

Category Baseline (Jan 2018) Update (Jun 2019) Update (Jun 2020) Update (March 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium Medium High High
Country Strategy Medium Medium High High
Digital Health Interventions High High High High
Source Code Accessibility High High High High
Funding and Revenue Medium Medium Medium Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High High High High
Community Governance Medium Medium Medium High
Software Roadmap Medium High High High
User Documentation Medium Medium High High
Multi-lingual Support Medium High High High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium Medium Medium Medium
Software Productization Low Low Medium Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium Medium Medium Medium
Security Medium Medium Medium High
Scalability Medium Medium High High

PCMT

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium
Country Strategy Medium
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High
Community Governance Medium
Software Roadmap High
User Documentation High
Multi-lingual Support High
Software
Technical Documentation High
Software Productization Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium
Security Medium
Scalability Medium

Pharmadex

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium
Country Strategy Medium
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High
Community Governance High
Software Roadmap High
User Documentation High
Multi-lingual Support High
Software
Technical Documentation High
Software Productization Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium
Security High
Scalability Medium

Reveal

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium
Country Strategy Low
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility Medium
Funding and Revenue Medium
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement High
Community Governance High
Software Roadmap Medium
User Documentation Medium
Multi-lingual Support Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium
Software Productization Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium
Security High
Scalability Medium

SanteMPI

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Low
Country Strategy Low
Digital Health Interventions High
Source Code Accessibility High
Funding and Revenue Low
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium
Community Governance Medium
Software Roadmap Medium
User Documentation Medium
Multi-lingual Support Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium
Software Productization Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility High
Security High
Scalability Medium

SORMAS

Category Baseline (Jun 2017) Update
Global Utility
Country Utilization High High
Country Strategy Medium High
Digital Health Interventions Low High
Source Code Accessibility Medium High
Funding and Revenue High High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Low High
Community Governance High High
Software Roadmap Low High
User Documentation Medium High
Multi-lingual Support Low High
Software
Technical Documentation Medium High
Software Productization Low High
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Low High
Security Low High
Scalability Low High

Tamanu

Category Baseline (July 2021)
Global Utility
Country Utilization Medium
Country Strategy Medium
Digital Health Interventions Medium
Source Code Accessibility Medium
Funding and Revenue High
Community
Developer, Contributor, and Implementer Community Engagement Medium
Community Governance Medium
Software Roadmap Medium
User Documentation Medium
Multi-lingual Support Medium
Software
Technical Documentation Medium
Software Productization Medium
Interoperability and Data Accessibility Medium
Security Medium
Scalability Medium